The thing about denaturalizing people is that it’s pretty serious so like everything else if you are going to do it then you need due process and so on. You don’t want to set a precedent where people just denaturalize their enemies. You give the federal government power and they’ll also denaturalize far right people. Rather than actually denaturalize anyone, we should normalize telling very unpatriotic Americans that they should leave if they hate the country so much.
Agreed. This is why I emphasized choice (actually existing citizens who regard their birthright passport as a historical accident and prefer to swear allegiance to a blood-and-soil nation) and the example of Israel, which has a lot of due process:
> The law authorizes the minister of the interior to request judicial authorization for revoking the citizenship of a person who was convicted of an offense that the convicting court determined to be an “act of terrorism.”
> The minister may apply to the court only if the minister is satisfied, after giving the person an opportunity to argue their claims within seven working days, that the person or someone acting on their behalf and with their knowledge, received funds “in connection with terrorism.”
> The court will order revocation of citizenship within 30 days of the filing of a request unless it has determined, for special reasons to be recorded, that the revocation was not justified under the circumstances.
The thing about denaturalizing people is that it’s pretty serious so like everything else if you are going to do it then you need due process and so on. You don’t want to set a precedent where people just denaturalize their enemies. You give the federal government power and they’ll also denaturalize far right people. Rather than actually denaturalize anyone, we should normalize telling very unpatriotic Americans that they should leave if they hate the country so much.
Agreed. This is why I emphasized choice (actually existing citizens who regard their birthright passport as a historical accident and prefer to swear allegiance to a blood-and-soil nation) and the example of Israel, which has a lot of due process:
> The law authorizes the minister of the interior to request judicial authorization for revoking the citizenship of a person who was convicted of an offense that the convicting court determined to be an “act of terrorism.”
> The minister may apply to the court only if the minister is satisfied, after giving the person an opportunity to argue their claims within seven working days, that the person or someone acting on their behalf and with their knowledge, received funds “in connection with terrorism.”
> The court will order revocation of citizenship within 30 days of the filing of a request unless it has determined, for special reasons to be recorded, that the revocation was not justified under the circumstances.
From https://www.loc.gov/item/global-legal-monitor/2023-03-06/israel-citizenship-or-residence-of-terrorism-offenders-who-receive-compensation-from-palestinian-authority-to-be-revoked/